The boardAI, LLMs, ML and cognitive neuroscience

Ship of Theseus

Ship of Theseus

I swapped the 31 parts of one language model, Qwen, one at a time for the matching parts of another, DeepSeek. After every swap I asked the hybrid who it was.

“Hello! I'm an AI assistant created by {{ company }} to help with your tasks.”A hybrid with 26 of its 31 parts from DeepSeek
  • The ships in the middle forget their name. In 1,745 of 1,920 answers they named neither model
  • Identity sits near the output. Swapping from that end, the ship calls itself DeepSeek after about 5 parts, against about 22 from the input end

Code and paper ↗

November 2026Theseus's ship had every plank replaced until none of the original wood was left. Both models come from the same Qwen pretraining run, so a part of one fits into the other. The design and five hypotheses were written down before the main run, which took 4.9 hours on two Kaggle GPUs.