Paperlane

no. 16 · Tuesday 17 November 2026

On the optimality of the HOD dichotomy

Gabriel Goldberg, Jonathan Osinski and Alejandro Poveda

math.LO · v2

Abstract

In the first part of the manuscript, we establish several consistency results concerning Woodin's HOD hypothesis and large cardinals around the level of extendibility. First, we prove that the first extendible cardinal can be the first strongly compact in HOD. Second, answering a question in \cite{CFH}, we prove that the first supercompact cardinal can be the first strongly compact, non supercompact, of HOD. We extend a former result of Woodin by showing that under the HOD hypothesis the first extendible cardinal is $C^{(1)}$-supercompact in HOD. We also show that the first cardinal-correct extendible may not be extendible, thus answering a question by Gitman and Osinski \cite[\S9]{GitOsi}. In the second part of the manuscript, we discuss the extent to which weak covering can fail below the first supercompact cardinal $δ$ in a context where the HOD hypothesis holds. Answering a question of Cummings et al. \cite{CumFriGol}, we show that under the $\mathrm{HOD}$ hypothesis there are many singulars $κ<δ$ where $\mathrm{cf}^{\mathrm{HOD}}(κ)=\mathrm{cf}(κ)$ and $κ^{+\mathrm{HOD}}=κ^{+}.$ In contrast, we also show that the $\mathrm{HOD}$ hypothesis is consistent with $δ$ carrying a club of $\mathrm{HOD}$-regulars cardinals $κ$ such that $κ^{+\mathrm{HOD}}<κ^{+}$. Finally, we close the manuscript with a discussion about the $\mathrm{HOD}$ hypothesis and $ω$-strong measurability.

fields
Logic
pdf ↗ page arXiv:2411.03558 ↗