Paperlane

no. 16 · Tuesday 17 November 2026

On statistical and causal models associated with acyclic directed mixed graphs

Qingyuan Zhao

math.ST · v3 · 38 pp

Abstract

Causal models in statistics are often described using acyclic directed mixed graphs (ADMGs), which contain directed and bidirected edges and no directed cycles. This article surveys various interpretations of ADMGs, discusses their relations in different sub-classes of ADMGs, and argues that one of them—the noise expansion (NE) model—should be used as the default interpretation. Our endorsement of the NE model is based on two observations. First, in a subclass of ADMGs called exogenously bidirected graphs (which retain most of the good properties of directed acyclic graphs and bidirected graphs), the NE model is equivalent to many other interpretations, including the ordinary Markov and nested Markov models. Second, the NE model for an arbitrary ADMG is exactly the union of the observed margins of NE models on its exogenously bidirected expansions. This property is referred to as completeness, as it shows that the model does not commit to any specific latent variable explanation. In proving the nested Markov property, we also develop an ADMG-based theory for causality and its complete characterization via the potential outcome calculus. Finally, we compare the NE model with the closely related but different interpretation of ADMGs as directed acyclic graphs (DAGs) with latent variables that is commonly used in the literature. We argue that the ``latent DAG'' interpretation is mathematically unnecessary, makes obscure ontological assumptions, and discourages practitioners from deliberating over important structural assumptions.

comments
38 pages
fields
Statistics Theory
pdf ↗ page arXiv:2501.03048 ↗