no. 17 · Wednesday 18 November 2026
Generalized Centralizers and Polynomial Equivalence of Matrices: Answers to Questions of Dolinar, Guterman, Kuzma, and Markova
Abstract
For $n\times n$ matrices $A$ and $B$ over a field and a scalar $ω\ne0$, let $\mathcal C_ω(A)=\{X:AX=ωXA\}$. If $ω$ is a root of unity of order $q\ge2$, then $\mathcal C_{ω^j}(A)=\mathcal C_{ω^j}(B)$ for all integers $j$ if and only if each of $A$ and $B$ is a polynomial in the other with exponents $\equiv1\pmod q$. Over algebraically closed fields, for $ω\ne1$, all $A$, and scalars $\varepsilon\ne0$, we describe all $Y$ with $XY=\varepsilon YX$ for all $X\in\mathcal C_ω(A)$. Let $a(μ)$ be the size of the largest Jordan block of $A$ at $μ$, or $0$ if there is none. If $\varepsilon$ is a power of $ω$, all such $Y$ are polynomials in $A$ if and only if $a(ωμ)=a(μ)$ for all $μ\ne0$, or this fails only at some $ν$ and at $ω^{-1}ν$, where $A$ has a single largest Jordan block at $ν$ and $a(ων)=a(ω^{-1}ν)=a(ν)-1$. This answers two questions of Dolinar, Guterman, Kuzma, and Markova. If $ω\ne1$ has finite order, then for such $A$, $\mathcal C_ω(A)=\mathcal C_ω(B)$ exactly when $A$ and $B$ are polynomials in each other of this form. For all other $A$ some $B$ that is not a polynomial in $A$ satisfies $\mathcal C_ω(A)=\mathcal C_ω(B)$ if the field has more than $n^2+1$ elements. In the $ω$-commuting digraph of Raja and Vaezpour, with an edge from $A$ to $B$ if $AB=ωBA$, vertices with edges to and from the same vertices are twins. Over fields with more than $2n^2+1$ elements we determine the vertices $A$ whose twins are all polynomials in $A$, and describe these twins. We find all $A$, $B$, and $k\ge2$ for which the kernel of $(X\mapsto[A,X])^k$ is the set of $X$ with $[X,[X,\ldots,[X,B]\ldots]]=0$ ($k$ brackets), where $[X,Y]=XY-YX$. Apart from scalar $B$, this happens only in characteristic $\ne2$, for $k=2$ and $2\times2$ matrices that generate the same quadratic extension.
- comments
- 41 pages, 5 figures. Substantially revised and expanded, with new results, corrections of errors in v2, and extensive changes to the structure and exposition
- fields
- General Mathematics