no. 11 · Monday 9 November 2026
Revisiting the Algebraic and Analytic Descriptions of Quantum Mechanics
Abstract
The Wintner-Wielandt theorem exposes a fundamental incompatibility between the canonical commutation relation (CCR) and the Hilbert-space formulation of quantum mechanics. While the conventional approach preserves the CCR by extending the Hilbert-space framework to a rigged Hilbert space, this work develops the complementary alternative. Retaining the Hilbert space, the unavoidable trace obstruction requires a boundary modification of the CCR, consistently realizable only in a space of finite, albeit arbitrarily large, dimension. In this setting, the eigenvalue problems of position and momentum admit explicit solutions within the Hilbert space. We show that the highest-energy components of the position eigenvectors retain a non-vanishing uniform weight, implying that the full spectrum remains relevant. The resulting autonomous matrix algebra also yields a new physical observable, the action difference. In the position basis, this observable gives rise to a momentum matrix with a discrete Cauchy kernel. After an alternating phase transformation, this matrix acts on plane waves in the infinite equidistant lattice model as the Schroedinger momentum operator, revealing a structural connection between the algebraic and analytic approaches. This framework retains the standard Hilbert-space spectral theory and remains closely connected to the familiar analytical structure of quantum mechanics, including the momentum operator and the uncertainty principle.
- comments
- 17 pages
- fields
- Quantum Algebra