Paperlane

no. 5 · Friday 30 October 2026

Maximality Levels of the classical permutation group in the quantum permutation group

J. P. McCarthy

math.QA · v2

Abstract

Progress on the conjecture of Banica and Bichon that the classical permutation group is a maximal quantum subgroup of the quantum permutation group remains limited to a handful of small-parameter results. By Tannaka–Krein duality, any counterexample to this Maximality Conjecture must arise from a category strictly intermediate between the category $\mathcal{NC}$ of non-crossing partitions and the category $\mathcal{P}$ of all partitions. Any such exotic category must therefore contain a linear combination of crossing-partition vectors. The categories generated by $\mathcal{NC}$ together with some such vectors are studied, with a number of generation results. It is shown that no exotic category can contain a linear combination of three crossing-partition vectors, and, using an argument of ChatGPT to account for a five-dimensional gap, there is no exotic category distinguished from $\mathcal{NC}$ or $\mathcal{P}$ at moments of order six.

comments
v2: Substantially revised and expanded. Maximality at moment level six established for all $N$ with assistance from ChatGPT. Includes a new computational appendix and publicly available Maple code
fields
Quantum Algebra, Operator Algebras
pdf ↗ page arXiv:2603.21759 ↗