Paperlane

no. 12 · Tuesday 10 November 2026

The consistency strength of the failure of amenable C-sequences

Gabriel Fernandes

math.LO · v3 · 40 pp

Abstract

We determine the consistency strength of the existence of a regular uncountable cardinal carrying no amenable $C$-sequence. It is equiconsistent with the existence of an inaccessible cardinal $κ$ which is $Π^1_ξ$-indescribable for every $ξ<κ^+$ in the transfinite second-order hierarchy of indescribability. For the lower bound, we prove that the failure of amenability at $κ$ implies that $L$ contains such a cardinal at or below $κ$, using constructible guessing sequences, correct constructible levels, and a transfinite induction. For the upper bound, we prepare the cardinal so that every proper initial segment of a full Hechler iteration of length $κ^+$ preserves weak compactness. Each final $C$-sequence appears at a bounded stage and is captured at the next stage on a stationary set; the remaining closed iteration preserves that capture.

comments
Updated the submission metadata. The upper bound is reduced from a $Π^2_1$-indescribable cardinal to an inaccessible $κ$ that is $Π^1_ξ$-indescribable for every $ξ<κ^+$. We now also establish an exact lower bound in $L$, determining the consistency strength and proving equiconsistency.40 pages
fields
Logic
pdf ↗ page arXiv:2610.09086 ↗