Paperlane

no. 7 · Tuesday 3 November 2026

On the lower bound of the refined Bessis–Moussa–Villani conjecture: proof of the cases S_{6,3} and S_{7,3} for 3x3 matrices

Daniel Hägele

math.RA

Abstract

For Hermitian matrices $α,β$ let $\A_{n,m}(e^α,e^β)$ be the average of the traces of all words with $n$ letters $e^α$ and $m$ letters $e^β$. The refined Bessis–Moussa–Villani conjecture contains the lower bound $\A_{n,m}(e^α,e^β)\ge\Tr e^{nα+mβ}$ (Tr denotes the trace), which for $n=m=1$ is the Golden–Thompson inequality. We prove this lower bound for all $n+m\le7$ when the matrices have size at most three, and for $\min(n,m)\le2$ in every dimension. In all these cases we prove the stronger inequality $\A_{n,m}(A,B)\ge\Tr(A^{n/m}B)^m$ for positive semidefinite $A,B$, or its mirror image with the roles of $A$ and $B$ exchanged; the lower bound of the refined conjecture follows from the Araki–Lieb–Thirring inequality. The cases with three letters $B$ in dimension three, $(n,m)=(3,3)$ and $(4,3)$, are reduced by an exact identity and the inequality of arithmetic and geometric means to a polynomial inequality in two variables, which is certified in exact rational arithmetic by Bernstein expansion on three boxes. The certificate is a short program in the ancillary files.

comments
Proof by Claude (Anthropic) checked by Gemini Opus (Google). The author guided Claude in finding the proof
fields
Rings and Algebras, Mathematical Physics, Operator Algebras
pdf ↗ page arXiv:2611.00129 ↗