Paperlane

no. 12 · Tuesday 10 November 2026

Group-Conditional Conformal Risk Control: Exact Guarantees, Limits, and Overlapping Extensions

Tareq Aldirawi and Wenge Guo

math.ST · via stat.ML · 68 pp

Abstract

We study group-conditional conformal risk control (CRC) for disjoint and overlapping groups under bounded monotone losses. For disjoint groups, we establish exact finite-sample conditional risk control, two-sided bounds on the group-restricted risk, and fundamental limitations arising from local support and calibration-rank granularity. For overlapping groups, we study two exactly valid approaches: group-restricted calibration followed by union deployment, and direct calibration of the deployed prediction-set family. We characterize the union's limiting reconciliation gap, identify conditions for its disappearance, and establish sharp lower bounds for structured losses in specified product-form models. We also demonstrate a strict size advantage for direct calibration in an ordinal model. Experiments show that direct calibration can reduce prediction-set size, but its efficiency depends on group structure, loss type, and shape fitting. Results on historical diabetic-retinopathy scores further illustrate these tradeoffs. Overall, local support, reconciliation slack, and threshold heterogeneity determine efficiency, with neither approach uniformly dominating.

comments
68 pages, including 40 pages of appendices
fields
Statistics Theory
pdf ↗ page arXiv:2611.10472 ↗