Paperlane

no. 16 · Tuesday 17 November 2026

A counterexample to the Jordan tuple conjecture of Ball and Helton

Eric Evert and Scott McCullough

math.FA

Abstract

This article constructs a pair of bounded commuting 3-symmetric operators with no Jordan-family extension. The operators are coordinate multipliers on a Sobolev space of functions with values in three dimensional complex Euclidean space with an equivalent Hilbert norm. Their quadratic symbol has no operator polynomial factorization, even with an auxiliary target Hilbert space. The construction transfers the nonfactorability of the matrix quadratic used by Russo to the symbol of a commuting 3-symmetric tuple. The factorization approach of McCullough–Russo and Russo then supplies the obstruction to a Jordan-family extension.

fields
Functional Analysis, Classical Analysis and ODEs
pdf ↗ page arXiv:2611.19373 ↗