Paperlane

no. 16 · Tuesday 17 November 2026

Frege's logic in Grundgesetze is nonclassical

Bruno Bentzen

math.HO

Abstract

I show that the axioms and rules of inference about the horizontal in the subsystem of Grundgesetze without value-ranges fail to capture its intended interpretation. That is, I build a nonstandard model in which $-a$ is the true iff $a$ is not the false, thereby confirming a conjecture made by Landini that $a \to (-a) = a$ is not provable in this subsystem. This motivates our main result, namely, soundness and completeness proofs for the first-order fragment without value-ranges with respect to a new nonclassical semantics of boolean truncation. Simply put, the widespread assumption that Grundgesetze's first-order logic is classical first-order logic is mistaken.

journal
Notre Dame Journal of Formal Logic, 67(3), pp. 437-455, 2026
fields
History and Overview, Logic
pdf ↗ page arXiv:2611.19892 ↗